From North Ferry:

Long Island Expressway to last exit (#73); follow Country Road #58 (which becomes Route 25) East to Greenport.  This road will take you through several small towns, with small town traffic.  Follow signs for the Shelter Island Ferry and take ferry to Shelter Island. 

Once on Shelter Island, follow route 114 South for about 1 ½ miles to the IGA Supermarket (it is a small market which will be on your right).  As Route 114 veers to the  right at the Supermarket, you do not follow it,  but rather you go straight ahead onto Manwaring Road.  Continue until you reach a small traffic circle and turn right onto St. Mary’s Road.  Turn left at the first road, which is Burns Road.  Follow Burns Road past the stop sign (at Cartwright Road).   St. Gabriel’s is the second driveway on the right as you approach the water.

Location and Directions   

From South Ferry:

Sunrise Highway, Route 27 East.  Follow Route 27 to exit 8 on the left, Sandy Hollow Road to North Sea Road; turn left at the light.  Follow North Sea Road to Noyack Road; it will bend to the right.  Follow  Noyack  Road until you see the “Waterside Restaurant” on the left.  Turn left after the “Watersisde” onto Long Beach Road.  Follow to blinking Red Light.  Go straight on Route 114 North and follow signs to North Ferry and take ferry to Shelter Island.

Once on Shelter Island, follow Route 114 north to first traffic circle.  At the circle Route 114 turns left; do not follow 114, instead go straight onto Cartwright Road.  Follow Cartwright Road about 3/4 of a mile to Burns Road.  Turn right onto Burns Road St. Gabriel’s is the second driveway on the right as you approach the water.